Europe
2025.03.14 23:54 GMT+8

Explainer: Germany's new debt settlement - and where it might go wrong

Updated 2025.03.14 23:54 GMT+8
CGTN
Explainer: Germany's new debt settlement - and where it might go wrong

Germany's conservative leader and would-be next chancellor Friedrich Merz has agreed what amounts to a fiscal policy sea-change with support from the Social Democrats (SPD), his likely coalition partner and the Greens.

What have they agreed, and what could still go wrong?

 

What have the three parties agreed?

After marathon talks, Merz's conservative bloc, the SPD and the Greens agreed to exempt security spending, very broadly construed, above 1 percent of economic output from the constitutional "debt brake" spending cap.

Spending on civil defense, IT security and "aid to states attacked in violation of international law" - a clear reference to Ukraine - will count as defense spending, meaning that in theory Germany can borrow unlimited sums to finance them.

They also agreed to create an off-balance-sheet special fund worth $543 billion to finance infrastructure, of which a fifth will be spent by the governments of Germany's 16 states. In addition, states will themselves be allowed to borrow up to 0.35 percent of GDP above the debt brake - giving them some $17 billion in spending room.

A further $108 billion from the fund will be used to stock up a climate and transformation fund that was created by the Greens when they were in charge of climate policy in Chancellor Olaf Scholz's outgoing government.

 

How were the Greens won over?

Just a day before Merz announced the agreement, the Greens were signalling they might not back the conservatives' and SPD's plans for boosting defense spending, saying they were concerned about the haste with which it was being passed and were worried the money would be frittered away on tax cuts.

The creation of some $126 billion in spending money for the states is a significant win for the Greens, since they are in government in seven of the 16 states.

The climate money is also important for a party that has made climate change mitigation a central pillar of its policy platform.

 

Does Merz have the votes?

Both measures need the support of two thirds of the Bundestag, the German parliament. In the old Bundestag, which is still in session, the combined votes of the conservatives, the SPD and the Greens clear that threshold with 30 votes to spare.

That buffer is important, given the possibility of ill or dissenting members in the 733-member parliament.

German Chancellor-in-waiting Friedrich Merz and CSU regional group leader Alexander Dobrindt announce their agreement with the Greens. /Axel Schmidt/Reuters

Merz spent the election campaign promising not to open the spending taps, only to announce a tectonic shift in German fiscal policy days after winning. Some legislators in his Christian Democrat (CDU) party and its Bavarian CSU allies may feel that is too sharp a U-turn, or that the SPD, the junior party in the planned coalition, has been given too much leeway.

Merz said on Friday he was confident the deal would pass.

 

Could legal challenges sink the package?

The measures, which include constitutional amendments, will be passed by the old Bundestag. Once the new lower house elected on February 23 is seated, the conservative-SPD-Green caucus would no longer suffice for two-thirds, giving the military-skeptic Left party the power to block it.

Both the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) and the Left party, which gained most in February's national election, launched urgent legal challenges against what they say is a maneuver to thwart the will of a parliament elected less than two weeks ago.

Germany's powerful Constitutional Court has a history of overriding government decisions, including in core matters of budgetary policy. 

The Court's skepticism about special funds of the kind now planned paved the way for the fall of Chancellor Olaf Scholz's government and the February early election that he lost.

However, on Friday afternoon Germany's constitutional court threw out several challenges by opposition parties, paving the way for parliament to convene next week to consider the proposals – with that two-thirds majority expected to be successfully reached.

 

The final hurdle: The upper house 

The Bundesrat, the appointed upper house of Germany's bicameral parliament, represents the governments of the 16 states that make up the federation.

The states, which for years have complained that they bear the brunt of Germany's fiscal squeeze, have every incentive to pass the loosening package, since they will be among its major beneficiaries.

But the conservatives, SPD and Greens still need the backing of one more party for it to pass the Bundesrat: that could be the Left, its populist splinter the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), the FDP or the Bavarian Free Voters party.

The AfD is not an issue here, since it does not serve in a state government, and Bundesrat members are appointed by state governments, not voters.

The BSW, Kremlin-friendly in its rhetoric, would be unlikely to back measures to increase defense spending, and the Left is also opposed to defense spending. The FDP, pro-Ukraine and pro-military spending, dislikes excessive borrowing.

That means Bavaria's Free Voters, sticklers for fiscal discipline from Germany's wealthiest region, are likely to play a crucial role. They have declined to commit so far, but many analysts think they could be persuaded with the right offer.

Source(s): Reuters
Copyright © 

RELATED STORIES