Why is the Queen involved in Boris Johnson's Supreme Court case?
Gary Parkinson
Europe;UK

Translating...

Content is automatically generated by Microsoft Azure Translator Text API. CGTN is not responsible for any of the translations.

Error loading player: No playable sources found
02:38

On 30 January 1649 in London's Whitehall, King Charles was executed by beheading. Although the restoration 11 years later returned his son Charles II to the throne, it was in a parliamentary monarchy: ever since, reflecting Parliamentarians' victory in the English Civil War, the sovereign has been the head of state in name only. 

No monarch has vetoed an Act of Parliament since 1708 and none has dismissed a prime minister since 1834. Theirs is usually a purely ceremonial role, rubber-stamping the decisions of the government. 

On 28 August 2019, Prime Minister Boris Johnson asked Queen Elizabeth II to prorogue (temporarily suspend) the current session of Parliament. The government stated the suspension was to prepare a new legislative agenda, but opponents suggested it was to halt parliamentary debate over Brexit, with the Speaker of the House of Commons calling it a "constitutional outrage." The Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled the suspension illegal, but the High Court in London disagreed, so it has been referred to the Supreme Court for a decision.

 

Why is the Queen involved in this Supreme Court case?

The Queen suspended Parliament as head of state, but only on the advice and direction of the prime minister as head of government. As CGTN's Andrew Wilson explains: "It's not Buckingham Palace that runs this country, but the Palace of Westminster."

 

What is the Queen's role in politics?

As with every monarch, it's purely symbolic and certainly not partisan. As sovereign, she is head of state but does not run the government. She opens Parliament with a speech which merely maps out the government's plans. Once Parliament votes through a law, it is taken for royal assent, but this is again a formality – remember, no Act of Parliament has been refused in more than 300 years.

This has become a more contentious point as Boris Johnson has been accused of being disingenuous when seeking royal assent to prorogue. Meanwhile, former prime minister David Cameron's recently released memoirs suggest he tried to use the Queen to influence the September 2014 referendum on Scottish independence. 

 

What happens now?

After three days of hearings, the Supreme Court's 11 justices have retired to consider a verdict on the legality of the prorogation. Firstly, they have to decide whether it is a matter of politics, in which the Supreme Court should not meddle, or a matter of law, in which it should. If it is a legal matter, should they command the prime minister to reconvene Parliament? Their decision is expected early next week. 

 

Main picture: Queen Elizabeth II at the State Opening of Parliament (Credit: Carl Court/Pool via AP)

MORE FROM CGTN
China's top political advisor meets Finnish parliament speaker
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

China

13:03, 07-Apr-2025

Malaysian PM: Southeast Asia must 'stand firm' against U.S. tariffs
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

Asia Pacific

10:33, 07-Apr-2025

Iranian FM says Iran not yet hold any negotiations with U.S.
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

Asia

02:19, 07-Apr-2025

'Hands Off': Europeans rally against Trump's policies
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

Europe

01:52, 07-Apr-2025

TOP NEWS
Global financial markets extend losses amid Trump tariff crisis
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

Business

15:24, 07-Apr-2025

Qingming Festival: New consumption frontiers energize China's market
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

China

04:25, 07-Apr-2025

EU seeks unity in first strike back at Trump tariffs
{"type":2,"value":"CGTN","commentator":[],"valueShow":true,"commentatorShow":false}

World

02:53, 07-Apr-2025